How to compare accounting software

Accounting software should support accurate records and a useful month-end review. It is not a substitute for deciding who codes transactions, checks exceptions and approves reports. Start with a sample month of the firm's actual documents, with sensitive details removed for demos, before comparing subscriptions.

What should the sample month contain?

For an illustrative eight-person company, include 30 sales invoices, 40 supplier bills, two bank accounts, staff expenses and one corrected invoice. These counts are fictional. Ask a vendor to show how it imports, matches, corrects and reports those items. IRAS's corporate record-keeping requirements are the official starting point for a company; IRAS's GST invoicing guidance applies where the business is GST-registered and the specific rules are relevant. Check current requirements with a qualified accountant rather than assuming the software automates every obligation.

Decide whether the owner, employee or outsourced bookkeeper enters bills and who reviews reconciliation. Our bookkeeping-service guide helps define the human scope; the invoicing-system guide focuses on customer billing. Accounting software may include invoicing, but compare the full record and reporting workflow separately.

What should a quote include?

Give each vendor the same user count, transaction volume, bank feeds, required reports, historical data and support level. Request setup, migration, subscription, add-ons, bank or payment integration, accountant access, training, support and export. A fictional Tool A may cost less monthly but charge for additional users and custom reports; Tool B may cost more and include those features. Compare a twelve-month total at the expected volume and a higher-volume scenario. Ask what happens if the business changes bookkeepers.

If customer or staff information enters the system, PDPC's data-protection obligations frame access and retention questions. Use named roles rather than shared owner credentials. Ask where data is stored, how corrections are logged and what format can be exported at contract exit. PDPC's processing-clauses guide helps review a vendor relationship involving personal data. Do not assume that a cloud backup means the business can independently recover all records.

What is a meaningful trial?

Reconcile the sample month and compare the closing balances, unpaid-invoice list and expense report with the existing records. Ask the accountant or bookkeeper to review exceptions. Try exporting documents and the audit trail, not just a summary PDF. Record manual steps that remain and assign an owner. The operations topic offers related controls. You can send Methodology an accounting-tool question for editorial guidance. We do not provide accounting advice or promise software referrals.

Ask the provider to demonstrate a correction after a period is reviewed. Who can change the entry, what trace remains and how does the accountant see the difference? A correctable mistake is normal; a hidden edit is a control problem. Include a test of bank-feed interruption and duplicate import. For the fictional company, two bank accounts create a simple reconciliation case that a polished sales demo might skip. If the vendor cannot show an understandable exception report, consider a smaller trial before migration.

Have the owner and external accountant agree which report is authoritative at month end, and who signs off any unreconciled balance before numbers are used for management decisions.

Ask for a sample monthly close checklist before inviting the wider team into the trial.

Common questions